Silicone Breast Implant Update

Since the wide release of silicone breast implants by the FDA in November of 2006, I have not used a single saline implant. In fact, my surgery center is sending our supply of saline implants back to the manufacturer to make room for silicone implants. On the rare occasion in which we need saline implants, we will have them shipped special order from the implant manufacturer.

For the past fifteen years, 90% of the breast implants used in the United States were saline. During that same time period, over 90% of the breast implants placed in much of the rest of the world were silicone. Most plastic surgeons anticipate that in time, over 90% of the implants used in the U.S. will be silicone.

When patients ask me, "Dr. Ryan, which implants are better, saline or silicone?", I respond that, like everything else in life, they each have their pros and cons, so I can't say that one is "better" than the other. I tell my patients that before 1992 (when he FDA put restrictions on the use of silicone implants), over 90% of implants placed were silicone and that I anticipate that we will return to close 90% usage in this country.

When patients ask me, "But aren't silicone implants dangerous?", I respond "Of course they're dangerous! We doctors love doing dangerous things to our patients all the time! And the malpractice lawyers love it even more!" I then explain to the patient, after we both finish laughing, that there is no way that I -- or any other doctor -- would ever do a procedure or use a device that we feel is dangerous. I then recite the many well-done, peer-reviewed scientific studies that refute that there is any link between silicone breast implants and cancer, autoimmune disorders or any number of other diseases that people have tried to link with silicone breast implants over the years.

In summary, it appears that silicone breast implants are here to stay and that the vast majority of surgeons and patients are welcoming their return.